Texas Democrats: Do Not Trust Elon Musk

by | May 15, 2020 | Economy, Policy

It is rare for someone to publicly admit they are breaking the law, but for Elon Musk that’s just another afternoon tweet.

On Monday, via Twitter the controversial billionaire announced his Tesla plant in Fremont, California would be reopening despite county and state lockdowns. In addition to being on the “front line,” Musk requested if anybody were to be arrested, it should be him.

In re-opening the plant and bringing back furloughed workers, Musk caps off a dramatic stand-off and online tantrum where he threatened to relocate his Tesla factory to Nevada or Texas. While most would ignore these threats as the rants of a temperamental billionaire, several Texas lawmakers urged Musk to carry through. While it’s aggravating, but not surprising, to see our Governor stooping to such a level, it’s positively embarrassing to see respected Democrats join in.

It’s also a little ironic since Texas is one of a handful of states that has banned Tesla’s direct-to-buyer model. (Car dealerships are one of the most powerful lobbying groups in Texas.) But perhaps folks like the Attorney General or State Senator James Hughes are willing to re-negotiate.

Musk has been adroit at keeping himself in the headlines with tabloid fodder, which has obscured some of his very serious legal cases. While he is currently the CEO of Tesla, he had to resign the role of Chairman after a deal with the Securities and Exchange and Commission. (Though Musk is often referred to as Tesla’s founder, it was actually incorporated by Martin Everhard and Marc Tarpenning).

Last year was a legally busy year for Musk. In addition to the SEC ruling, in a separate case a federal judge ruled that Tesla violated U.S. labor laws. Many California state leaders have taken issue with Tesla’s union-busting reputation and have called out the company for exploiting low-wage workers. In December, Musk was given a judicial reprieve after he was cleared by a jury of defamation after he called a diver attempting to rescue stranded Thai children in a cave a “pedo guy.” 

With COVID-19, Musk once again found himself in the news. He was one of the first and most vocal public figures to downplay any threat of the virus. He also said there would be close to zero deaths by the end of April. In early May he tweeted “Tesla stock price too high imo” and predictably the stock price fell 12 percent.  

Now with the possibility of Tesla actually relocating to Texas, it’s time for progressives to stop the foolishness, not encourage it. Musk is erratic (to put it mildly). Tesla has violated labor laws. And Wednesday it was revealed that workers fearful of returning to the factory amid a pandemic were told they will lose their unemployment benefits.

This state likes to tout its business savvy. But there’s no reason to believe Tesla wouldn’t even make financial sense.  

Last year in my home city, local officials made a fanfare of Uber declaring Dallas its newest major hub. The city council approved unanimously over $9 million in economic incentives and a five-year tax break. The 2,500 new hires that Uber promised the city has since been delayed to 2025.

Though nobody could have predicted a global pandemic would completely upend the ridesharing business, Uber was probably not the wisest investment to begin with. In 2019 the company lost $8.5 billion. Financial analysts are still puzzling as to when the company could begin to see any profit. Last year, Uber also had to pay $4.4 million into a fund settling sexual harassment claims. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission found that the company had “engaged in a culture of sexual harassment and retaliation.”

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. This state has spent enough money bailing out foolish projects like fatality-in-waiting water parks, flopped golf courses, and highways that make it harder for commuters.

There’s nothing we can do about Republicans clamoring for Musk’s attention. But we can hold progressives accountable to the very values that got them elected in the first place. No Texas Democrat should even think for a moment in trusting Elon Musk.

If Musk wants to leave California, there’s Mars. Although I hope for his sake by the time that happens, Tesla technology is actually indestructible.

Photo: Daniel Oberhaus/ Wikimedia Commons

+ posts

A longtime writer and journalist, Jessica was thrilled to join the Texas Signal where she could utilize her unique perspective on politics and culture. As the Features and Opinion Editor, she is responsible for coordinating editorials and segments from diverse authors. She is also the host of the podcast the Tex Mix, as well as the co-host for the weekly SignalCast. Jessica attended Harvard College, is a onetime fitness blogger, and has now transitioned to recreational runner (for which her joints are thankful).

Are you tired of Texas Republicans pushing big lies and trying to steal your vote? So are we, that’s why we’re fighting back against the right-wing lie machine. Our commitment to ethical, fact-based journalism is vital to our democracy, and we can’t do it without you. Consider donating today to help us stay in this fight.

Continue Reading

Texas isn’t your campaign slogan

Texas isn’t your campaign slogan

On Friday, a video went viral on Twitter of Vice President Kamala Harris campaigning for Virginia gubernatorial candidate Terry McAuliffe.  Democrats campaigning for one another is common in the dynamics of politics because, like the familiar phrase, it's not...

Greg Casar wants to undo Abbott’s worst laws

Greg Casar wants to undo Abbott’s worst laws

The Signal recently spoke with Greg Casar, a progressive Austin city councilman considering a run for Congress in Texas’ 35th congressional district.  A former labor organizer with the Workers Defense Project and the youngest person ever elected to Austin City...