Texas lawmaker proposes ‘age-appropriate’ book bill

by | Nov 17, 2022 | Education, Texas Legislature

There are still two months before the 88th Texas legislative session starts in early 2023. Still, Texas Republicans’ pre-filing records show banning more books in public schools and deciding what students can read in a classroom will be a top priority for the legislature. 

For context, on Monday, Republican State Representative Tom Oliverson, HD-130, pre-filed HB 338, which forces publishers to add ‘age-appropriate’ ratings on any books or written materials. 

According to the bill, publishers have 120 days to change the rating if the state doesn’t agree. 

However, if the publisher doesn’t change the rating, they risk their book being blacklisted and pulled from shelves. 

Moreover, this proposed bill applies to any library book or written material in the state’s 1,026 public school districts or any open-enrollment charter schools. 

Director of Free Expression and Education Programs at PEN America, Jonathan Friedman, said this proposed bill gives the state “incredible power” during a press conference on Wednesday. 

“It’s pretty unprecedented for the state [or] any kind of government to institute a rating system in this way,” Friedman said. “In the film or music industry, rating systems are imposed by the industry; they are not imposed by the state. Given the climate that we’re seeing in many states, this isn’t just age ratings.” 

Friedman added that publishers and librarians already use categories to differentiate material and understand that each student has different reading levels, regardless of grade level. 

“This is an incredible power to vest in state government which can be easily politicized, which can be manipulated, which can be ultimately subjective about what age everybody in school gets to read things,” he said. “We have to remember that school libraries not only serve students, they also serve families.” 

This bill comes as Texas lawmakers and Texas Board of Education trustees have successfully banned around 801 books in public schools and local libraries. 

It’s important to note that most books banned included content on historical events like slavery and the Holocaust, race, political violence, LGBTQ themes, and more. 

Such titles as Toni Morrison’s Beloved, The Diary of Anne Frank, and Margaret Atwood’s novel, now turned television show The Handmaid’s Tale, are just a few examples of banned books.

According to a September poll by the EveryLibrary Institute, most American voters disapprove of the slew of book bans across the country, with 92 percent opposing the ban on classic novels and 91 percent opposing a ban on children’s books. 

Nonetheless, Katy ISD student Cameron Samuels said these book bans are rooted in political motivation and hurt students more than anything. 

“Proponents of book bans aren’t considering how losing access to affirming literature and resources that are vital to us will affect students’ education or well-being,” Samuels said. “Our schools are not battlefields for politics, and especially students are not political pawns.”

+ posts

Kennedy is a recent graduate of the University of St.Thomas in Houston where she served as Editor-in-Chief of the Celt Independent. Kennedy brings her experience of writing about social justice issues to the Texas Signal where she serves as our Political Reporter. She does everything from covering crime beats, Texas politics, and community activism. Kennedy is a passionate reporter, avid reader, coffee enthusiast, and loves to travel.

Are you tired of Texas Republicans pushing big lies and trying to steal your vote? So are we, that’s why we’re fighting back against the right-wing lie machine. Our commitment to ethical, fact-based journalism is vital to our democracy, and we can’t do it without you. Consider donating today to help us stay in this fight.

Continue Reading

Anti-Abortion Group Sues FDA Over Abortion Pill

Anti-Abortion Group Sues FDA Over Abortion Pill

One of the key groups behind the overturning of Roe v. Wade has filed another anti-abortion lawsuit, this one in Texas. Alliance Defending Freedom sued the FDA last week to reverse federal approval of mifepristone, a medication that can terminate an early pregnancy....

A Conversation With Mihaela Plesa

A Conversation With Mihaela Plesa

Despite volunteering, protesting, and voting, after former President Donald Trump was elected in 2016, first-generation Romanian-American Mihaela Plesa said something told her it wasn’t enough.  So as one does, she dropped everything to be as civically engaged as...

Ted Cruz’s No Good, Very Bad Election

Ted Cruz’s No Good, Very Bad Election

In the leadup to the midterm elections, Ted Cruz promised a “red tsunami.” That prognostication turned out to be wrong. With the re-election of Senator Catherine Cortez Masto in Nevada, Democrats officially retained control of the Senate. There are still outstanding...